When it’s time to upgrade your bathroom, one of the biggest decisions you’ll face is this: should you go with a walk in shower, a bathtub, or both?
It’s not just a style choice—it affects your home’s resale value, daily comfort, and even how you use the space. At Johnny Home Improvement Contractor Inc, we’ve helped hundreds of homeowners design bathrooms that reflect their style and needs. Here’s a breakdown of everything you need to know to make the best choice for your bathroom remodel.
Walk In Showers: Sleek, Stylish, and Practical
Walk in showers have become the go-to feature in modern bathroom remodels—and for good reason. They’re streamlined, elegant, and perfect for anyone seeking a spa-like experience at home.
Pros of Walk In Showers
- Space-Saving Design: Ideal for smaller bathrooms where a tub may feel bulky.
- Modern Aesthetics: Sleek glass enclosures or open-entry styles elevate any bathroom.
- Easy Entry and Exit: Especially great for seniors or people with mobility concerns.
- Low Maintenance: Fewer crevices means less scrubbing.
- Water Efficiency: Uses less water per use than most bathtubs.
Cons of Walk In Showers
- Not Ideal for Bath Lovers: If you enjoy soaking, this may be a dealbreaker.
- Potential Water Splash: Without a well-designed enclosure, water can splash onto the floor.
- Resale Consideration: Some homebuyers still prefer a tub—especially families with young children.
Bathtubs: Comfort, Luxury, and Family-Friendly
Bathtubs bring a sense of comfort and indulgence that’s hard to beat. Whether it’s for bathing kids or soaking after a long day, the bathtub still holds its place in the modern home.
Pros of Bathtubs
- Relaxation Factor: Perfect for unwinding and stress relief.
- Ideal for Families: Parents of young children typically prefer having at least one tub in the house.
- Classic Luxury Appeal: Freestanding or clawfoot tubs can be a showstopper.
- Boosts Resale Value in Certain Markets: Especially in suburban homes or family neighborhoods.
Cons of Bathtubs
- Takes Up More Space: Not ideal for compact bathrooms.
- Water Consumption: Tubs use more water compared to showers.
- Less Accessible: Stepping in and out may be difficult for older adults or those with mobility issues.
Should You Consider Having Both?
If your bathroom remodel budget and square footage allow it, adding both a walk in shower and a bathtub can offer the best of both worlds. You’ll meet the needs of multiple lifestyles—and your bathroom becomes a luxurious retreat with maximum versatility.
At Johnny Home Improvement, we often design master baths that include a custom tile walk in shower and a freestanding tub—creating a blend of functionality and beauty that homeowners love.
Which One Adds More Resale Value?
Here’s the deal:
- A walk in shower appeals to modern tastes and is a top choice in urban homes or condos.
- A bathtub, on the other hand, remains a key selling feature in homes with multiple bedrooms—especially for families.
The real value? A bathroom remodel done right—regardless of which option you choose—can return up to 60-70% of your investment when it’s time to sell.
Consider Your Lifestyle and Space
Ask yourself:
- Do you take more showers or baths?
- Is your space limited?
- Will aging in place be important in the future?
- Do you plan to sell your home in the next few years?
Your answers will point you toward the right solution. And if you’re still unsure, our remodeling experts at Johnny Home Improvement Contractor Inc will help you weigh your options during a free consultation.
Custom Shower and Tub Combo Installations
Yes, you can have your cake and soak in it too. Custom-built shower and tub combos are a great way to merge the functionality of a walk in shower with the comfort of a tub—all in one well-designed space.
We build personalized layouts that fit your bathroom’s footprint and your design preferences, including:
- Built-in tiled shower/tub combos
- Frameless glass surrounds
- Wall-mounted fixtures and storage niches
- Mood lighting and water-saving fixtures
Let’s Build the Bathroom You’ve Been Dreaming Of
At Johnny Home Improvement Contractor Inc, we specialize in high-quality, custom bathroom remodeling that fits your lifestyle and boosts your home’s value.
Whether you choose a walk in shower, a bathtub, or both—we’ll guide you through every step, from design to final tile.